Why Did Hermione Not Save Dobby

I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more

Can Hermione save Dobby?

Hermione is silent, implying she didn’t have her healing potion with her or she knew Dobby’s injury is too serious to save him. All in all, it probably wasn’t in anyone’s power to save him.

Why did Hermione Obliviate herself?

And so, she chose to erase herself from her parents’ minds. Hermione wanted to keep her parents safe from potentially running into Voldemort by ensuring he had no reason to come a-knocking. She also promised that she would find them and reverse the magic when all was said and done.

Could they have healed Dobby?

Here is the list of all known healing spells. None of them can probably heal such a fatal injury Dobby has suffered. In the book Hermione stuffed the beaded bag in her sock to save it. In the film, the snatchers got the beaded bag.

Why did Harry bury Dobby without?

It is because of Harry’s past and Harry thinks that it is more meaningful burying someone in the muggle way because its more personal and from the heart and it shows how much Harry cared for Dobby that he wanted to incorporate all of Harry’s life into the death of Dobby and he wanted to share that part of his life too, …

Why could Hermione save Dobby?

Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Hermione was not an experienced healer. She lacked the skills to do much more advanced magical healing, and likely knew that this situation exceeded anything she was capable of fixing.

Does Dobby get saved?

He’s killed in “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows,” the final book in the series. Dobby rescues Harry, Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, and several other anti-Voldemort fighters from Malfoy Manor — just before Voldemort arrives — and whisks them away to a safe place.

What did Hermione put on their hands after they jumped off the dragon?

She uses essence of dittany to regrow skin on their hands. They didn’t mention heat in the movie, perhaps because if their hands were blistered, their faces would have been, too, and no one wants that.

How is Dobby treated?

Serving the Malfoy family (? –1993) Dobby was the resident house-elf of Malfoy Manor, serving Lucius Malfoy, his wife Narcissa, and their only son Draco. They treated Dobby with unkindness and cruelty, often reminding him to perform extra punishments on himself when he did something disagreeable to them.

Why did Hermione erase herself from her parents?

Why Hermione Gave Her Parents New Identities It was clear that they would stop at nothing to get hold of Harry and his closest allies, including Hermione. In order to keep her parents out of the war, Hermione needed to effectively wipe any information her parents had on her, her friends, and the wizarding community.

Can Hermione reverse Obliviate spell?

After Voldemort’s death, Hermione is able to lift the spell on her parents. This suggests that the Memory Charm does not remove a memory from a person’s mind, but rather obscures it in some way.

Why does Hermione Obliviate her family?

Hermione cared very much about her parents. She had to obliviate them because she didn’t want them to get killed during the war, and made them want to move to Australia and have new identities instead of being Grangers. She was powerful enough to reverse any charm she put on them.

Why didnt they heal Dobby?

Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Hermione was not an experienced healer. She lacked the skills to do much more advanced magical healing, and likely knew that this situation exceeded anything she was capable of fixing.

How was Dobby treated?

Serving the Malfoy family (? –1993) Dobby was the resident house-elf of Malfoy Manor, serving Lucius Malfoy, his wife Narcissa, and their only son Draco. They treated Dobby with unkindness and cruelty, often reminding him to perform extra punishments on himself when he did something disagreeable to them.

How old was Dobby the elf?

Dobby was alive from 1970 – 1981 and he was probably 6 then. and with the time that has passed, he would have been 37 when he died.

Why did they not save Dobby?

Also, Dobby’s injury was so severe that there was very little time in which to save him. He and Harry landed somewhat far from Ron and Hermione so Hermione wouldn’t have immediately known that she could/should look for her dittany in time to save him. Highly active question.

Why did Harry dig Dobby’s grave by hand?

Harry wanted to show some respect and dug his grave by his hands without any use of magic. Digging his grave with just a flick of wand would have implied that it was another death for the greater good. But Harry wanted his death not to be treated like that. He wasn’t just another dead for the greater good.

Is Dobby’s grave still there 2021?

Is Dobby’s grave still there today? YES! Although in the books Dobby died in 1998, the free elf’s grave is still kept alive by fans on Freshwater West Beach.

Why are the elves slaves in Harry Potter?

Rowling revealed that elves were brought to Hogwarts by Helga Hufflepuff, in hopes to give them good work conditions – meaning getting paid and not being abused, which is what happened in most families.

Why did Hermione not help Harry save Dobby?

Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Hermione was not an experienced healer. She lacked the skills to do much more advanced magical healing, and likely knew that this situation exceeded anything she was capable of fixing.

What did Harry Ron and Hermione rub on their hands?

She used essance of Dittany on Ron when he was splinched and it was in a similar bottle. So, she used dittany on their hands to make them feel better after hanging onto a rough dragon for a few hours.

Does Harry save Dobby?

In “Chamber of Secrets,” Harry Potter manages to get Dobby freed by handing Tom Riddle’s diary back to Lucius Malfoy, encased in an old sock, which Malfoy tosses in Dobby’s direction, unintentionally setting him free.

Who did Dobby save?

In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, during the Skirmish at Malfoy Manor, Dobby snaps his fingers and disarms Narcissa Malfoy. In the second book, Harry asks Dobby to promise to not save his life again, but 5 books later Dobby does because he is the last hope of getting out of Malfoy Manor.

Does Dobby sacrifice himself?

After Harry helps him win his freedom from the sinister Malfoy family, Dobby pledges his loyalty to the Hogwarts student. Eventually, he sacrifices himself so that Harry and his friends could go on to save the world from Lord Voldemort.

What does Hermione put on their hands after they jump off the dragon?

So, she used dittany on their hands to make them feel better after hanging onto a rough dragon for a few hours. Essence of Dittany. In the book, they applied it to their burns because the treasure in the Lestrange vault burned their skin.

What liquid did Hermione give Harry and Ron to rub on their hands right after they got out of the water following their escape from Gringotts?

it was essence of dittany, the dragon’s back was rough and they got their hands scratched so Hermione gave them The Essence of Dittany. Essence of dittany. It is a healing potion. The trio had received a lot of burns in the lestrage vault, so they used essence of dittany to cure their burns.

What was Hermione holding in her hand when she was petrified?

For one, Hermione has not failed to solve the mystery that has proved so elusive to Harry and Ron; she sought knowledge in the library and found it in the form of the basilisk description she has balled into her hand. Everything fits. All of the mysteries, voices and attacks suddenly make sense.

What was Hermione holding in her hand at the end of Goblet of Fire?

At the end of Goblet of Fire on the train back to Kings Cross the trio are sitting in the compartment when Hermione tells Harry and Ron about Rita being an unregistered animagus. She then shows them the jar with the beetle in it.

How was Dobby punished?

Anytime Dobby does something wrong, the Malfoys make him punish himself, such as when they made him iron his hands for being absent, or flog him visciously for letting their dinner burn.

Is Dobby abused?

We don’t know specifically what kind of abuse Dobby endured during his time with the Malfoys but given how cruel Lucius and Draco were in the stories we can assume that Dobby was physically, mentally, and verbally abused. Dobby told Harry that he was used to getting death threats “five times a day” from the Malfoys.

How is Dobby freed?

In “Chamber of Secrets,” Harry Potter manages to get Dobby freed by handing Tom Riddle’s diary back to Lucius Malfoy, encased in an old sock, which Malfoy tosses in Dobby’s direction, unintentionally setting him free.

What is Dobby personality?

Dobby has an ESPF personality due to his honest and humble nature. He is eager to help his friends, but he doesn’t brag about his powerful magical skills. He is dedicated to the right causes and doesn’t possess an evil bone in his body.

Did Hermione’s parents get their memories back?

Several years later, however, Hermione was forced to alter her parents’ memories and give them new identities as Wendell and Monica Wilkins, to protect them from the Death Eaters. After the Second Wizarding War ended, Hermione found Mrs Granger and her husband in Australia and returned their memories.

Can Hermione undo the Obliviate spell?

Lockhart’s memory loss is permanent, but the Memory Charm doesn’t necessarily have to be. After Voldemort’s death, Hermione is able to lift the spell on her parents.

Did Hermione’s parents forget her forever?

Hermione returned her parents’ memories. In the movies, Hermione cast the spell “Obliviate” on her parents, making them forget they ever had a daughter. Since they were muggles, she wanted to keep them safe from Voldemort’s influence. “Obliviate” is permanent, so the tragedy is horrific.

Can Hermione reverse Obliviate on her parents?

Is there a way to restore memories after an obliviate spell? Yes, it’s been confirmed that after the Second Wizarding War she went to Australia to undo the effects of her memory charm. J.K. Rowling: They are two different charms.

How did Hermione reverse the Obliviate spell on her parents?

It says Obliviate in film and unknown charm in books. People it WASN’T OBLIVIATE!!! obliviate completely removes someone’s memory. Hermione SPECIFICALLY states that she MODIFIED her parent’s memories.

Can you be Unobliviated?

The Memory Charm (Obliviate), also known as the Forgetfulness Charm, was a charm that could be used to erase specific memories from an individual’s mind.

Why would they not save Dobby?

So Hermione didn’t have anything to save Dobby. Even if Hermione had the Dittany essence, she would not have been able to save Dobby. With the Dittany, even Ron’s healing was slow. It also did not seem to help with blood loss, as per the comment about Ron’s pallor.

Did a chandelier fall on Hermione?

With a grinding sound, the chandelier above them starts to fall. Bellatrix leaps out of the way, and the chandelier falls on Hermione and Griphook, who is holding the Sword of Gryffindor.

Related Search to why did hermione not save dobby:

  • why didn’t hermione use the time turner to save dumbledore
  • why did dobby have to die
  • why didn’t hermione save dobby reddit
  • could hermione have saved everyone
  • what did bellatrix do to hermione
  • could dobby have been saved
  • how old was dobby when he died
  • why didn’t hermione show bellatrix’s wand
  • why didn’t hermione save snape
  • hermione dobby
  • could harry have saved dobby
  • did hermione obliviate her parents in the book
  • why did hermione end up with ron
  • why did hermione die
  • why did hermione like ron
  • why did hermione obliviate her parents reddit
  • did hermione restore her parents memory
  • when does hermione obliviate her parents in the movie
  • why did hermione kiss harry
  • why didn’t dobby heal himself
  • why didn’t hermione end up with harry
  • how did dobby die
  • how did the gaunts get the resurrection stone
  • where was dumbledore buried
  • who killed antioch peverell
  • harry potter dobby death scene
  • is salazar slytherin related to the peverells
  • dobby’s grave
  • harry potter dobby
  • why did they let dobby die
  • what movie does dobby die in part 1 or 2
  • how does dobby die in the book
  • dobby death
  • does dobby come back to life
  • who killed dobby
  • dobby is free
  • how old is dobby
  • who does ron turn into in deathly hallows: part 2
  • essence of dittany
  • where is hagrid in deathly hallows part 2
  • dragomir despard
  • where did harry get the mirror shard
  • 7 horcruxes
  • how did luna get back to hogwarts
  • who does hermione turn into with polyjuice potion in deathly hallows
  • dobby and winky
  • master has given dobby a sock
  • dobby the house-elf
  • dobby quotes
  • what happened to hermione’s parents after the war
  • are hermione’s parents muggles
  • why did hermione obliviate her parents
  • what did hermione do after hogwarts
  • hermione granger parents real names
  • hermione’s parents actors
  • can hermione obliviate her parents
  • obliviate spell reverse
  • obliviate spell hermione
  • obliviate spell wand movement
  • how did hermione restore her parents’ memories
  • what spell does hermione use on her parents
  • is the obliviate spell permanent
  • obliviate spell harry potter
  • why didn’t hermione help harry when dobby was dying
  • why didn’t hermione fall in love with harry
  • why didn’t hermione give bellatrix’s wand
Rate this post

Related Posts

Leave a Comment